Good news!! I finally decided on a printer and got it set up. I decided to go with another Brother, the HL-L2395DW. I received it December 30th, but I have dreaded taking down the old one and setting up the new one, so it sat in its box until tonight. I needed to print something, and tech support is closed on the weekend, so I decided to attempt setting it up on my own. Happily, all went well, and I have printed my first page on it with no problems.
This is an exceedingly quiet printer, and it does not take up too much more room than my old Brother. It cost me roughly $20 or so more than my old printer, but in addition to printing, this one also photocopies and scans! After reading tons of reviews, I downloaded the drivers and manuals, etc., instead of attempting to use the CD that came with it. That went smoothly. Set up went very smoothly overall. I was worried about setting it up on WiFi, but all I had to do was specify I wanted to set it up for WiFi, specify use my computer (the other choice was a mobile), type in my password whence prompted, and the printer found my computer and my WiFi with no other assistance from me and set up everything, thank heavens!
The only thing I did not set up was the scanning function because set up wanted me to specify a folder where I wanted scans to go. I have no idea about that, but I can get tech support to help me get it done one day next week. I have only used the printer once so far, of course, but this was probably the easiest set up I have ever done, and so far I am very pleased with my choice of printer. I think this is an excellent printer for the price point. I just hope it lasts a while longer than my old Brother. This one goes into sleep mode after so many minutes of not being used, but I want to talk to tech support about keeping it turned off whence not used. I do not do much printing. Sometimes I will go days and even weeks without printing anything. My old printer was always in standby mode, and I cannot help but wonder if that was what partly killed it after about 7 years. I hope this one will have a longer life, and I think keeping it turned off if not in use might help me to do that. Still need to figure out how to print from the mobile, too, but that is not urgent.
Anyway, I am a very happy HunnieBunnie right now!